Amazon Visa vs. Chase Freedom

[Debating]

I recently was told that my current reward card is being discontinued and that it will automatically roll over into the Chase Freedom card.

This didn't make me too happy, so I looked into other cards that suit my shopping habits. The best candidate thus far is the Amazon Visa.

I was hoping someone could help elucidate the differences between the two cards and which might be a better option.

AMAZON VISA:
1% on all purchases
2% at gas stations, restaurants, drug stores
3% on Amazon.com purchases

Reward points can go toward a variety of things, including Amazon purchases and cash. They expire after 4 years.

CHASE FREEDOM:
1% on all purchases
3% on promotional, rotating categories
up to 10 points on the dollar when shopping through Ultimate Rewards Mall (MAYBE even 20%)

Reward points can go toward a variety of things, including Amazon giftcards and cash back. Points do not expire.



Thus far, they seem a bit evenly matched, depending on where spending takes place. RIGHT NOW, the Amazon card is coming in at 13.24% APR and the Chase Freedom at 12.24 - 15.24% APR.

The rotating categories of the Freedom card kind of concern me. I wonder if the stability of the 2% rewards will be better with Amazon. Also, for anyone with the Freedom card, is the Ultimate Rewards Mall actually through Amazon? How have people found the additional points work? Or does the online store only hold special items and not things a person may actually want to buy on their own (without rewards - such as only specific promotional items)?

I also heard (though this may be for an older version of the Freedom card) that online purchases in general were awarded extra reward points. Is this still the case?

The majority of my online purchases are either through Amazon or with my cell phone company. So I would like to know if triple points with the Amazon card for Amazon purchases would ultimately outweigh randomized points for online purchases with the Freedom card.

Any additional information would be greatly appreciated. Thank you.

[MrCreditCard]

If the majority of your online purchase is with amazon and your cell phone company, then I would go with the amazon card. The new Chase Freedom is modeling after the Discover Card models where they allow you to earn anywhere from 5% to 20% (in discover's case) if you shop online but go through your discover account. So for example, instead of going directly to landsend.com, you log in to your discover account and go to landsend.com (same site). But discover has an arrangement with them and so you get that extra cash back.

If you are thinking about Chase Freedom, Discover is the better card IMO. But looks like amazon is the one for you...